Satisfaction Rankings of Auto Insurers in Oregon

JD Powers 2008 Auto Claims Satisfaction Study
Consumers Rate Auto Insurers

Insurers   Customer Satisfaction Rankings
State Farm 85.1%
American Family 82.0%
Progressive 82.0%
Liberty Mutual 81.7%
GEICO 81.5%
Nationwide 80.2%
Allstate 80.1%
Farmers 80.0%
Safeco 78.5%
AIG 78.0%

Society of Collision Repair Specialists
Satisfaction Ratings Survey
National Organization Rates Auto Insurers

   
  Insurers   Satisfaction Ratings  
20072008
   State Farm   8.26   8.30
 American Family   7.13   6.97
Farmers   6.90   6.41
Liberty Mutual 6.776.67
GEICO   6.69   6.22
AIG   6.68   6.72
Allstate   5.55   6.33
Nationwide 6.036.12
Progressive 5.094.79

The JD Powers national 2008 Auto Claims Satisfaction Study is based on 11,671 responses from auto insurance customers who filed a claim within the past 12 months. The study, fielded from July to August 2008, excluded customers who only had glass/windshield, theft/stolen vehicle, roadside assistance or bodily injury claims. The above insurers do business in Oregon.

 

The survey asked participants to rate their relationship with each of the included insurers on a 0-10 scale (with 10 being the highest and 0 the lowest.)

 

The JD Powers national 2008 Auto Claims Satisfaction Study is based on 11,671 responses from auto insurance customers who filed a claim within the past 12 months. The study, fielded from July to August 2008, excluded customers who only had glass/windshield, theft/stolen vehicle, roadside assistance or bodily injury claims. The above insurers do business in Oregon.

NW Automotive Trades Assoc.

OR Collision Repair Shops Rate Insurers
Insurers   Overall Grade
State Farm B+
Liberty Mutual C+
American Family C
AIG C
GEICO C-
Nationwide C-
Farmers D+
Safeco D+
Allstate D+
Progressive D

State of Oregon - Insurance Division
Consumer Guide to Insurance Complaints
Insurers Ranked by Complaint Records

Insurers Total OR Premiums   Confirmed Complaints   Rankings by Complaints filed
State Farm $344,701,74310911  
Nationwide$26,373,685913  
Liberty Mutual$28,691,4441718  
Safeco $143,064,0628619  
American Family$76,667,5515121  
Farmers $274,531,02718722  
GEICO $47,891,7773726  
Progressive$39,024,0683328  
Allstate $82,477,2587431
 

650 Oregon collision repair shops received surveys which graded insurers on how well each company's policies, attitude and payment practices ensure quality repairs and service for Oregon motorists.

 

After complaint indexes were computed by the Insurance Division, insurers were ranked by their complaint records. The above insurers handle about 95% of personal auto insurance in Oregon. The smaller the ranking number the better the complaint record.

 

© 2010 Oregonians for Safe Auto Repair